seaturtle.org : MTN : ARCHIVES : Sign In

The epibionts used in this study were opportunistically collected by Mote Marine Laboratory in Casey Key, FL from loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) while satellite tags were being attached (Marine Turtle Permits #126 & #155; Lener 2010) during the nesting seasons in 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2010, as part of a thesis to examine the association between epibionts and sea turtle migration (C. Lener, unpubl. data). The Deepwater Horizon (DWH) Oil Spill occurred from 20 April 2010 to 15 July 2010 at an offshore oilrig off the coast of Louisiana during the time of sampling. We reanalyzed the epibiont samples to evaluate changes in those communities on loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) before and after the DWH oil spill.
During the original study, collection of epibionts followed a standardized cleaning and collection procedure described in Pinou et al. (2019), but it was limited to the area of the carapace being cleaned for satellite tagging in order to minimize the stress to the turtles, decrease sample collection time, and adhere to Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission guidelines. Only visible epibionts were collected. Adhering to a small sampling area also improved future sampling reliability. All epibionts used in this study were deposited in the division of invertebrate zoology at the Yale Peabody Museum.
The DWH oil spill had far-reaching consequences for marine organisms in the Gulf of Mexico. The impact on water quality from the oil spill included surface oil reaching as far as Northwest Florida (Wang & Roberts 2013), and in silico studies suggested that dissolved hydrocarbons from the oil spill traveled as far south as Dry Tortugas, an island at roughly the same longitude as the Florida Keys (Weisberg et al. 2014). The planktonic larvae of many invertebrate turtle epibiont species are freely carried by the currents (Zardus & Martel 2002; Zardus & Hadfield 2004; Sloan et al. 2014), therefore, the turtles sampled in this study may have been exposed to water with affected epibionts without traveling in the reported oiled area. Exposure to oil and the dispersants used in oil spill clean-up can result in higher larval and adult mortality in zooplankton due to the accumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (Almeda et al. 2013a,b). Since marine epibionts are bioindicators for water quality (Chiarelli & Roccheri 2014), and water quality changed following the oil spill, we predicted that we would find a decrease in epibiont abundance and biodiversity collected from loggerheads in 2010 compared to earlier sampling years.
We compared the epibiont abundance per turtle (number of individual organisms collected from each turtle) for the pre-oil spill (mean ±SD = 264 ±339, n = 41) and post-oil spill turtles (mean ± SD = 780 ±944, n = 19). In contrast to the prediction that epibiont abundance would decrease after the spill, the abundance significantly increased (df = 20, ? = 0.05, tstat = -2.2, tcrit = 1.7, p = 0.027). Although outliers in abundance are present in both the pre- and post-oil spill groups, approximately 20% of the turtles in each group displayed unusually high epibiont loads equally, suggesting that the significant difference between pre- and post-oil spill epibiont communities is unlikely to be due to outliers in either group.
Next, we verified epibionts based on morphology, and recognized 21 different taxa (genus or higher classification) on pre-oil spill turtles and 22 taxa on post-oil spill turtles (Table 1, Fig. 1). We used the taxon data to compare pre- and post-oil spill turtle epibiont communities based on: 1) Simpson’s diversity index; 2) principal components analysis; and 3) Kruskal-Wallis tests of the abundance of each individual taxon, corrected for repeated measures using Bonferroni correction. Prior research of aquatic and marine invertebrate communities have found shifts in community structure along a tidal gradient (Frid & James 1989), a river gradient (Arscott et al. 2010), and following the introduction of an invasive species (Kaplan et al. 2017).
We calculated the Simpson’s diversity index (SDIs) using Excel for each individual turtle. When the SDIs of the pre-oil spill (mean ±SD = 0.36 ±0.18, n = 41) and post-oil spill turtles (mean ±SD = 0.40 ±0.20, n = 19) were compared with a one-tailed t-test assuming unequal variances, there was no significant difference found (df = 31, ? = 0.05, tstat = -0.70, tcrit = 1.7, p = 0.24). To test differences in epibiont community composition pre- versus post-oil spill, we performed a Principal Components Analysis (PCA) on the log-transformed data (Fig. 2). A PERMANOVA analysis (999 permutations) indicated the pre- and post-oil spill communities were overlapping but distinct (R2 = 0.09449, p-value = 0.001) (Fig. 2, left), with the post-oil spill community displaying a higher variance. The overlap between the two communities indicates the post-oil spill epibiont communities can resemble those of pre-oil spill (overlapping 95% confidence intervals), or that they may have a different assortment of epibiont taxa. There was a marked increase in the overall possibilities for epibiont community composition following the oil spill. The PCA loadings (Fig. 2, right) indicated that two obligate barnacles (Chelonibia spp., C. testudinaria) appeared to be negatively correlated with a group that included several non-obligate epibiont taxa as well as the obligate epibiont barnacle C. caretta. To evaluate taxon abundance changes after the oil spill, we compared the pre-oil and post-oil spill abundances of individual taxonomic groups using Kruskal-Wallis tests, with Bonferroni correction of p-values (Table 1). Three epibiont taxa differed significantly before and after the oil spill: C. testudinaria, Bivalvia, and, Copepoda. Chelonibia testudinaria, an obligate epibiont, significantly decreased in number following the oil spill (Kruskal-Wallis ?2 = 9.8249, p-value = 0.041328), while Bivalvia and Copepoda significantly increased (Table 1). These two taxa were not identified beyond the class/subclass level, and their status as obligate or non-obligate epibionts therefore cannot be determined.
We propose four alternative explanations for the epibiont community changes we observed: 1) sea surface temperature, 2) altered migration patterns, 3) altered turtle behavior due to oiling and/or disease and 4) altered survival and/or competition amongst marine invertebrates. First, the literature supports changes in marine invertebrate distribution in response to temperature changes. One common epibiont genus, Amphipoda, will preferentially move to areas with higher temperature, even when the salinity is not optimal (Meadows & Ruagh 1981). Additionally, a longitudinal study in the English Channel found that the warming climate has changed the distribution of certain zooplankton (Southward et al. 1995). Therefore, we evaluated whether sea surface temperature changes over the course of our longitudinal sampling align with increased population sizes of marine invertebrates. We analyzed published records of sea surface temperature (SST) in the water surrounding Casey Key from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and did not find a significant difference among the mean monthly temperatures during nesting seasons (May-July) across 2003-2019 (between groups: F = 0.14, Fcrit = 1.95, df = 16; Fig. 3). Therefore, the increase in epibiont abundance observed from post-oil spill samples is unlikely to be due to temperature.
Second, we can rule out the possibility that turtles altered their migration paths due to the oil spill. Scute samples collected from loggerhead turtles who foraged in the area affected by the oil-spill showed that they did not change their foraging patterns significantly in the wake of the oil-spill or during oil-spill cleanup (Vander Zanden et al. 2016). Since loggerheads retained high fidelity to their foraging grounds in spite of the oil spill, it is unlikely that the epibiont community changes resulted from the turtles encountering different epibiont communities on a different foraging route.
While a change in migratory behavior is unlikely, turtles may have come into contact with epibionts exposed to oil that were carried by the currents (Zardus & Martel 2002; Zardus & Hadfield 2004; Sloan et al. 2014). The current in the Gulf of Mexico has been shown to have a Westward flow from the Caribbean Sea, passing through the Yucatan Channel before looping around the coast of the Southeast United States and down past the West Florida Continental Shelf (Kinder 1983). The sea turtle tracking data from Mote Marine Laboratory shows that although the sampled turtles forage and travel in a variety of predictable locations, including the Yucatan Peninsula, Florida Keys, Florida Straits, Bahamas, Cuba, and Jamaica <https://seaturtle.org/tracking/>, all traveled inside the Gulf of Mexico in order to reach Casey Key, FL for nesting. Therefore, all turtles had an opportunity to come into contact with impaired planktonic epibiont larvae.
Our third alternative explanation for the observed changes in post-oil spill epibiont communities is altered turtle swimming and grooming behavior resulting from contact with oil or as a result of disease. The oil coating that forms on exposed skin and carapace may make it more difficult for turtles to practice regular grooming and remove epibionts as they would normally (Lutcavage 1995; Sloan et al. 2014), which could lead to increased epibiont colonization. The turtles sampled were not oiled, so this is an unlikely explanation for the increased epibiont abundance and disrupted epibiont community observed. Turtles with the condition Debilitated Turtle Syndrome (DTS) are also observed to have higher epibiont loads, due to the increased time they spend lethargically floating at the surface reducing grooming behaviors (Deem et al. 2009; Sloan et al. 2014). The turtles sampled in this study were nesting and not evaluated as debilitated,. Therefore, the significant change in post-oil spill epibiont community is not the result of turtles affected by DTS.
Although we did not test this, our fourth, and most likely explanation is that the increase in epibiont abundance and shifts in community composition are due to altered survival and competition among the invertebrate epibionts due to chemical changes in the water resulting from the oil and/or cleanup effort. For example, the effects of the Exxon-Valdez oil spill on marine invertebrates varied based on taxonomy; amphipod abundance declined at oil-heavy sites, whereas several other groups showed higher abundance and diversity, possibly due to decreased competition from amphipods (Jewett et al. 1999). After the Deepwater Horizon spill, saltwater marsh arthropod and marine invertebrate communities declined, but then recovered rapidly (2010-2011), and the marine snail Littorina showed no significant change, indicating that marine invertebrates vary in sensitivity to oil pollution (McCall & Pennings, 2012). The changing epibiont community profile suggested by these studies agrees with our observed differences in community structure and supports a need for research that studies bioindicators, which could in turn allow for early detection of impaired waters and sea turtle health (Nolte et al. 2020).
In our study, Chelonibia spp. was the most affected obligate epibiont after the oil spill. The decrease in frequency of the obligate Chelonibia testudinaria may provide opportunity for the congeneric C. caretta to colonize, or for diverse epibiont patterning that is not detected when C. testudinaria is present. Future monitoring at Casey Key may provide insight into the role of Chelonibia as a keystone obligate barnacle on loggerhead sea turtles. This study suggests that taxa with planktonic larvae, such as barnacles, most bivalves (Zardus & Martel 2002), and some copepods (Hirst & Kiørboe 2002), may be good bioindicators of water quality.
Taking into consideration the growth rates of Chelonibia and the distance from the oil spill to Casey Key, FL, we suggest it is plausible that turtles could have come into contact with impaired epibionts with sufficient time for the epibionts to attach and grow to a size where they were visible for collection. The straight-line distance between Macondo Prospect, the site of the spill, and Casey Key, FL is approximately 608 km (Google Earth). The barnacle Chelonibia testudinaria, which had a greater association with the pre-oil spill community than the post-oil spill community, takes 9 days in vitro at 25°C to reach its cyprid stage where it can attach to a host, and can grow faster in warmer temperatures as growth rate is directly related to temperature (Zardus & Hadfield 2004; Sloan et al. 2014). C. testudinaria grows fastest in these early stages and has been documented to reach 30.3 mm in 6 months (Doell et al. 2017) and to grow 4.29 mm per day with individual variability (Sloan et al. 2014). The zooplankton surviving the DWH oil spill could arrive to Casey Key in approximately 9 days based on the path of the Gulf currents and an approximate speed of 0.8 m/second reported by Kinder (1983). Since the current does not follow a straight line but rather a longer curved path, we can say that it would take some time period slightly over 9 days for the epibionts to travel the path of the current. This means that epibiont larvae had the opportunity to travel, attach to turtles, and grow to a size visible enough for collection at Casey Key, FL that summer. Although there are no studies on the growth rate of the other barnacles studied in this paper, we speculate that some species are sensitive to oil spills, supporting the significant decrease in C. testudinaria abundance we observed.
As the climate warms and further industrial accidents occur, marine organisms will experience environmental stressors. Therefore, it is important to understand how climate change and human activites will affect epibiotic frequency and community structure in the epipelagic zone because of the vital role they play in the planktonic food chain. This paper is a call to action for researchers to collect epibiont samples in the future and support long term monitoring and longitudinal data sets that can provide a temporal and spatial lens of a changing marine ecosystem.
Acknowledgements. We thank Dr. Tony Tucker and associates for their work in collecting the data used in this paper. Additionally, we thank Dr. John Zardus for sharing his epibiont literature and expertise, and Dr. Eric Lazo-Wasem (Yale Peabody Museum) for ]sharing his knowledge of invertebrates and helping to catalogue, identify, and store the epibiont samples. We also thank Dr. Nathan Robinson who was instrumental in obtaining sea surface temperature data for analysis. Finally, we extend a big thank you to Kristen Mazzarella and Dr. Jake Lasala of Mote Marine Laboratory for helping to access additional data on samples and for collaborating on future epibiont collection.
ALMEDA, R., Z. WAMBAUGH, Z. WANG, C. HYATT, Z. LIU & E.J. BUSKEY. 2013a. Interactions between zooplankton and crude oil: Toxic effects and bioaccumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. PLoS ONE 8(6): e67212.
ALMEDA, R., Z. WAMBAUGH, Z. WANG, C. HYATT, Z. LIU & E.J. BUSKEY. 2013b. Effects of crude oil exposure on bioaccumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and survival of adult and larval stages of gelatinous zooplankton. PLoS ONE 8(10): e74476.
DEEM, S.L., T.M. NORTON, M. MITCHELL, A. SEGARS, A.R. ALLEMAN, C. CRAY, R.H. POPPENGA, M. DODD & W.B. KARESH. 2009. Comparison of blood values in foraging, nesting, and stranded loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) along the coast of Georgia, USA. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 45: 41-56.
DeLONG, K.L, J.A. FLANNERY, R.Z. POORE, T.M. QUINN, C.R. MAUPIN, K. LIN & C.C. CHEN. 2014. A reconstruction of sea surface temperature variability in the southeastern Gulf of Mexico from 1734 to 2008 C.E. using cross-dated Sr/Ca records from the coral Siderastrea siderea. Paleoceanography 29: 403-422.
HOEGH-GULDBERG, O. & J.S. PEARSE. 1995. Temperature, food availability, and the development of marine invertebrate larvae. American Zoologist 35: 415-425.
INGELS, J., Y. VALDES, L.P. PONTES, A.C. SILVA, P.F. NERES, G.V.V CORREA, I. SILVER-GORGES, M.M.P.B. FUENTES, A. GILLIS, L. HOOPER, M. WARE, C. O’REILLY, Q. BERGMAN, J. DANYUK, S. SANCHEZ ZARATE, L.I. ACEVEDO NATALE & G.A.P. dos SANTOS. 2020. Meiofauna life on loggerhead sea turtles-diversely structured abundance and biodiversity hotspots that challenge the meiofauna paradox. Diversity 12: 203.
JEWETT, S.C., T.A. DEAN, R.O. SMITH & A. BLANCHARD. 1999. ‘Exxon Valdez’ oil spill: impacts and recovery in the soft-bottom benthic community in and adjacent to eel grass beds. Marine Ecology Progress Series 185: 59-83.
KALELI, A., A. CAR, A. WITKOWSKI, M. KRZYWDA, C. RIAUX-GOBIN, C.N. SOLAK, Y. KASKA, I. ZGLOBICKA, T. PLOCINSKI, R. WROBEL & K. KURZYDLOWSKI. 2020. Biodiversity of carapace epibiont diatoms in loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta Linnaeus 1758) in the Aegean Sea Turkish coast. PeerJ 8: e9406
LAZO-WASEM, E.A., T. PINOU, A.P. De NIZ, M.A. SALGADO & E. SCHENKER. 2007. New records of the marine turtle epibiont Balaenophilus umigamecolus (Copepoda: Harpacticoida: Balaenophilidae): new host records and possible implications for marine turtle health. Bulletin of the Peabody Museum of Natural History 48: 153-156.
LAZO-WASEM, E.A., T. PINOU, A.P. De NIZ, A. FEUERSTEIN. 2011. Epibionts associated with the nesting marine turtles Lepidochelys olivacea and Chelonia mydas in Jalisco, Mexico: a review and field guide. Bulletin of the Peabody Museum of Natural History 52: 221-240.
LENER, C. 2010. Using epibionts to predict loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) foraging grounds. MSc Thesis. Western Connecticut State University. 38p.
LIMA, G.M. & J.A. PECHENIK. 1985. The influence of temperature on growth rate and length of larval life of the gastropod, Crepidula plana. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 99: 55-71.
LUTCAVAGE, M.E., P.L. LUTZ, G.D. BOSSART & D.M. HUDSON. 1995. Physiologic and clinicopathologic effects of crude oil on loggerhead sea turtles. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 28: 417-422.
McCALL, B.D. & S.C. PENNINGS. 2012. Disturbance and recovery of salt marsh arthropod communities following BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill. PLoS ONE 7(3): e32735.
MEADOWS, P.S. & A.A. Ruagh.1981. Multifactorial analysis of behavioral responses of the amphipod Corophium volutator to temperature-salinity combinations. Marine Ecology Progress Series 6:183-190.
NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration), ERDDAP Database. Multi-scale Ultra-high Resolution (MUR) SST Analysis fv04.1, Global, 0.01°, 2002-present, Monthly. Dataset ID: jplMURSST41mday. https://coastwatch.pfeg.noaa.gov/erddap/griddap/jplMURSST41mday.html.
NOLTE, C.R., R. NEL & M.C. PFAFF. 2020. Determining body condition of nesting loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) in the South-west Indian Ocean. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 100: 291-299.
NOLTE, C.R., R. NEL & M.C. PFAFF. 2020. Determining body condition of nesting loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) in the South-west Indian Ocean. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 100: 291-299.
O’CONNOR, M.I., J.F. BRUNO, S.D. GAINES, B.S. HALPERN, S.E. LESTER, B.P. KINLAN & J.M. WEISS. 2007. Temperature control of larval dispersal and the implications for marine ecology, evolution, and conservation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(4): 1266-1271.
PFALLER, J.B., K.A. BJORNDAL, K.J. REICH, K.L. WILLIAMS & M.G. FRICK. 2007. Distribution patterns of epibionts on the carapace of loggerhead turtles, Caretta caretta. Journal of the Marine Biological Association, Marine Biodiversity Records 1: ed 36. DOI:10.1017/S1755267206003812.
PINOU, T., E.A. LAZO-WASEM, K. DION & J.D. ZARDUS. 2013. Six degrees of separation in barnacles? Assessing genetic variability in the sea turtle epibiont Stomatolepas elegans (Costa) among turtles, beaches and oceans. Journal of Natural History 47: 33-34.
PINOU, T., F. DOMENECH, E.A. LAZO-WASEM, R. MAJEWSKA, J.B. PFALLER, J.D. ZARDUS & N.J. ROBINSON. 2019. Standardizing sea turtle epibiont sampling: outcomes of the epibiont workshop at the 37th International Sea Turtle Symposium. Marine Turtle Newsletter 157:22-32.
RAMOS-RIVERA, B.S., H. CASTRO-MONDRAGON, J.G. KUK-DZUL, P. FLORES-RODRIGUEZ & R. FLORES-GARZA. 2021. Diversity of epibionts associated with Lepidochelys olivacea (Eschscholtz 1829) sea turtles nesting in the Mexican South Pacific. Animals: 11: 1734.
ROBINSON, N.J., R. MAJEWSKA, E.A. LAZO-WASEM, R. NEL, F.V. PALADINO, L. ROJAS, J.D. ZARDUS & T. PINOU. 2016. Epibiotic diatoms are universally present on all sea turtle species. PLoS ONE 11(6): e0157011.
ROBINSON N.J., E.A. LAZO-WASEM, B.O. BUTLER, J.D. ZARDUS & T. PINOU. 2019. Spatial distribution of epibionts on olive ridley sea turtles at Playa Ostional, Costa Rica. PLoS ONE 14 (9): e0218838.
ROBINSON, N.J. & J.B. PFALLER. 2022. Sea turtle epibiosis: Global patterns and knowledge gaps. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 10:844021.
SILVER-GORGES, I., J. INGELS, G.A.P. DOS SANTOS, Y. VALDES, L.P. PONTES, A.C. SILVA, P.F. NERES, A. SHANTHARAM, D. PERRY, A. RICHTERKESSING, S. SANCHEZ-ZARATE, L. ACEVEDO, A.J. GILLIS, S.A. CERIANI & M.M.P.B FUENTES. 2021. Epibionts reflect spatial and foraging ecology of Gulf of Mexico loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta). Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 9: 696412
SOUTHWARD, A.J., S.J. HAWKINS & M.T. BURROWS. 1995. Seventy years’ observations of changes in distribution and abundance of zooplankton and intertidal organisms in the Western English Channel in relation to rising sea temperature. Journal of Thermal Biology 20: 127-155.
SLOAN, K., J.D. ZARDUS & M.L. JONES. 2014. Substratum fidelity and early growth in Chelonibia testudinaria, a turtle barnacle especially common on debilitated loggerhead (Caretta caretta) sea turtles. Bulletin of Marine Science 90: 581-587.
VANDER ZANDEN, H.B., A.B. BOLTEN, A.D. TUCKER, K.M. HART, M.M. LAMONT, I. FUJISAKI, K.J. REICH, D.S. ADDISON, K.L. MANSFIELD, K.F. PHILLIPS, M. PAJUELO, & K.A. BJORNDAL. 2016. Biomarkers reveal sea turtles remained in oiled areas following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Ecological Applications 26: 2145-2155.
ZARDUS, J.D. 2021. A global synthesis of the correspondence between epizoic barnacles and their sea turtle hosts. Integrative Organismal Biology 3(1): obab002.
Table 1. Pre- and post-oil spill mean abundance of epibiont taxa (n = 60, df = 1). Note that several Amphipoda could not be identified to genus, and the obligate turtle epibionts Chelonibia testudinaria, Chelonibia caretta, and unidentified Chelonibia spp. were analyzed separately. P-values were adjusted with Bonferroni correction. Significance levels (* < 0.05, ** < 0.01, *** < 0.001)
Figure 1. Epibiont diversity and abundance on female loggerhead sea turtles before (2006-2008) and after (2010) the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Epibionts were collected during the nesting season and identified based on morphology.
.
Figure 2. Top. Principal Components Analysis of epibionts from loggerhead turtles collected before and after the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill (n = 60). Each point represents the epibiont community on an individual loggerhead. Labels on points indicate the following regions on routes taken by the turtles: A - Atlantic; B - Bahamas; C - Cuba; F - Florida Straits; G - Gulf of Mexico only (all routes included the Gulf of Mexico); K - Florida Keys; T - Texas; Y - Yucatan; Bottom. PCA Loadings showing epibiont taxa contributing to PCs, with vector length and color indicating the strength of contribution.
Figure 3: The average monthly sea surface temperature around Casey Key, FL (Latitude: 27 - 27.15°, Longitude: -82.6 -82.4°). Calculated with historical data from NOAA.